// ZDNET — INTELLIGENZA ARTIFICIALE
Managers are using AI to write performance reviews – and it shows
Does AI use help or hurt feedback at work? Here's what one survey found.
As AI use ramps up at work, where are the pros and cons, and for whom? New research from professional development firm Highwire shows where AI has entered the feedback loop — and where it’s both a potential problem and a solution for employee development.
Highwire surveyed 1,034 corporate employees on how AI is infiltrating manager-employee relationships. It found that 78% of managers reported using AI to “help draft, edit, summarize, or inform feedback or a performance review” in the last year. Most of those managers, perhaps unsurprisingly, noted that AI sped up the process of prepping that feedback (Highwire told ZDNET it did not ask managers what else they noticed about using AI).
Also: Nearly 70% of workers use AI regularly now – with no time to upskill
However, only 16% of non-managerial employees surveyed were told AI influenced their review. Maybe concerns about being perceived poorly for using AI are behind that drop in transparency: an Atlassian study from June found that owning AI use at work backfired.
The details of how managers are using AI for feedback matter here, though. Having an AI tool format or summarize human-written observations, for example, is a different level of intervention than handing AI some performance data and asking it to crank out a review top to bottom.
As for how that feedback is landing with employees: 54% of those surveyed said feedback “has become more specific and actionable.” But 34% found feedback more generic, and 32% said it was less useful. A third of employees potentially pulling less value from their reviews than before AI entered the picture isn’t minor, even if the majority is finding a benefit.
Also: What workers are really using AI for in 2026 – and what they aren’t
The survey also found that “nearly 1 in 4 employees now rehearse difficult workplace conversations with an AI tool.” Highwire frames this as the result of a vacuum: Only 44% of employees reported having their manager’s support to practice a high-stakes conversation or other difficult workplace scenario, far less than the 85% who say practice is key. AI is therefore filling a needs gap for nervous employees.
The findings about rehearsing with AI are echoed in AI video company Synthesia’s latest release, Sessions. The new feature lets employees practice conversations with one of the company’s AI avatars and get an assessment from an “AI coach” — essentially an automated, scaled version of the one-on-one training managers typically give to employees.